Create a scene in Editor
// Note that the Camera position is <0, 1.6, 0>
// Note that if you enter the scene with Alt+Ctrl+i you are looking at the scene from there
Move the camera to y=20M (up high), or <0, 20, 0>
Use Alt+Ctrl+i to confirm that the scene viewing initial camera position is high.
Publish the scene
Reload the scene
Camera is back at <0, 1.6, 0>

Editor sorely needs a multillevel undo/redo capability.
Recommend using:
Ctrl+Z to undo (multiple levels)
Ctrl+Y to redo (multiple levels)

It would be acceptable if the undo stack was cleared upon a save.

The Editor text chat window covers the bottom of the left hand "scenegraph" panel.
This can make it hard to see all the entity hierarchy in the scene.
This is made worse if you don't have a huge pixel array monitor.
For example, on a laptop with a 1920 x 1080 display, the chat window covers some of even the small number of objects in the default starting scene.
There is no ability to move, hide, or collapse the chat window.

Partial workaround
Press Ctrl+- to zoom out the panels until you can see.
This will never be a completely sufficient workaround for complex scenes

The IPFS address shows when you do a save.
But unless you capture it there, you don't have an easy way to get it later.
Does the Editor know the current IPFS? If so can there be a way to show it and/or better yet load it into clipboard?

Summary: what are the recommended practices for importing foreign objects into IPFS or other web storage and then getting them into the "inline" storage (in the A-Frame sense of "inline")?

This MIGHT only be a documentation request.

Steps to reproduce the UX problem:

1. Open editor, new or existing scene
2. In the DCL Editor scenegraph panel on left, click on Add... - .obj
   // see a selection tool appear at the origin
   // optionally move this to somewhere you want the object to initially appear.
3. Scroll to bottom of the Components panel on right
   // observe a place to enter paths for .mtl and .obj
   // If you look at the paths for the DCL logo disk object, you see paths that are relative to some root which is nowhwere documented what it is.
   // /obj/Decentral_2.mtl
   // /obj/Decentral_2.obj
4. Wonder how to get objects and materials uploaded in a way that they can then be used with paths like this
5. Tried putting the .obj and .mtl into the A-Frame Asset Uploader (UploadCare) https://cdn.aframe.io/
6. Tried putting the full paths with domain names of the uploaded files into the scene.
7. The object appeared (the mtl didn't, but that may be a different issue)

Steps to reproduce:

1. open editor on a scene
2. press "h" to see the Shortcuts popup
3. try/learn the various shortcuts. They are very helpful
   // expect: all of them to work
   // actual: Tab doesn't work as documented

Steps to reproduce:
Place an entity at a higher Z elevation, (anything too high to see with current camera position), or just Lose track of where it is off-camera in a Scene.
Try to find it
// You have to use right mouse click and drag the camera up or around to find it

Suggested solution:

1. When you select an object in scene entity list on left, the camera moves to it.
   or
2. There is another (zoom to) icon on entities in the scene entity list that can be clicked to move camera there.

It would be good to have a way to know the build number and/or datetime of the Editor you are currently using.
This would be especially helpful for testing / issue reporting. If an issue is reported without that information, it adds work and/or uncertainty for anyone dealing with whether and how to fix it and whether a new build is newer than a fix, e.g. for verification of fix.

Although the reported IPNS and IPFS when reopening a scene match what was reported when it was last saved, the formatting of the information is different between the pages (like whether there is more than the hash), and the use of hottext.

I'd say: if having the hotlink is useful, use that format on both pages.

If you have multiple.obj entities in scene, selecting one, then another, the .obj and .mtl urls in the Component panel don’t update.

Workaround: click some primitive between the .objs.

(I didn't test what happens if you save in the state where the paths were displayed wrong.)

That's the error you get when you visit https://editor.decentraland.org and click on "Load sample scene".

Work done in the Editor during alpha will be dead-ended (just for early learning/testing), until or unless there is a way to migrate an alpha 'scene' to real land after Terraforming.

Possible solutions would be

• the ability to import an ltgf file (that was saved from the Editor using the button in top right corner)
• a utility for importing a scene from IPFS/IPNS into a new scene on Land.

The Editor needs a help menu, button, or icon.

There are two types of help that should be made available:

1. Shortcuts (which can be obtained today using the "h" key)

2. Bringing up an Editor Help documentation web area. This could for now be a Wiki URL, either in Github or in wiki.decentraland.org

When 2nd person enters a new scene, the boilerplate objects might change from where the scene creator has them

Steps:
Dave created a new scene (on mac)
Carl enters the scene
Carl sees the bottom blue bar superimposed with the top one (wrongly located)

This might be an issue pertaining to persistence problems.
For example, Carl's PC browser cache (Chrome) might be remembering the location of a boilerplate component from an previously viewed or edited scene.

One place for Editor documenting could be to enable the Wiki in this github editor repository
Another could be an established/permanent page in the wiki.decentraland.org wiki.

(Once it is decided, there should be way to get to it from a help control in the Editor, which is covered in Issue #12)

Open Loader
Select land (buy it if you don't own it).
Open editor on your land
Place some object in the scene.
Move the X or Z position of the well off of land you own.
// Expected some sort of constraint barrier against doing so and a warning/explanation.
Publish scene.
Close editor
Reopen Editor from the same land selection
// expected: The object isn't off your land
// actual: the object got saved on the other owner's land.

This is probably related to #16
But this issue is better described -- here are specific reproducible steps that can be performed by one person with two browsers.

Tested with the current/latest Editor on editor.decentraland.org starting on Nov 13, 2017 at 8:06PM Central (GMT-6)

In browser 1: (e.g. Chrome)
Create a scene
// e.g. https://editor.decentraland.org/scene/CarlFravelTest%202017%2011%2013%202006
Save scene
Scene "CarlFravelTest%202017%2011%2013%202006" saved to IPFS
The IPNS locator is: /ipns/QmUCg2BKf2MojPcEVMKZN6eYmq4mSQKNMzJmW3jbW1APQT
The IPFS hash pointed to is:
Continue editing

In Browser 2: (e.g. FireFox)
Open the the same Scene URL
See the same hierarchy

In browser 1:
Delete the middle blue bar //
// scene has no now, just 2 and 4

In browser 2:
// expected: middle bar is gone
// actual: (bottom bar) is gone from scene and from hierarchy

In BOTH browsers, using the scenegraph on the left, select
// expected: top bar is selected in each browser
// actual: in browser 1, boxes 2 and 4 are now colocated where the top bar should be.

In browser 1:
Drag in the direction of the blue arrow
In browser 2:
// expected: will have moved
// actual has moved

In browser 1:
Save
Scene "CarlFravelTest%202017%2011%2013%202006" saved to IPFS
The IPNS locator is: /ipns/QmUCg2BKf2MojPcEVMKZN6eYmq4mSQKNMzJmW3jbW1APQT
The IPFS hash pointed to is: QmayG4KJVkYPkuUdemHv1Y9gp5qv5Y8i7hwvD9Yn8LQq7m

Do not save in browser 2.

Hi!

Cant to upload obj file, 19mb

Save and reload of scene does not get the changes back.

// Steps to repro
Create new scene
Move or delete boilerplate objects
Save scene
Capture the hash number
Close editor
Open editor on the same using the URL with the scene name
// expect: see changes
// actual: see original boilerplate
Open editor on the same using the URL with the scene hash
// expect: see changes
// actual: see original boilerplate

Dave (on Mac) and Carl (on PC) go into same scene (not yet saved)
Dave and Crrl both select the same object
Dave moves it
// expected: Carl sees both the object and its selection tools move
// actual: Carl sees object move, but selection tools stay behind
Carl hovers over an arrow on selection tool, it jumps to the correct new place.
// Note, the opposite is not true: If Carl moves the object, Dave sees the object and selection tools both move properly.

// note, a variable may be who created the scene. This scene was probably created by Dave.

This is relatively minor, no harmful side effects have so far been noticed.

Open editor on a scene.
Publish the scene (v1)
Make a noticable change to the scene.
Publish the scene (v2)
Right after clicking [Submit] on the MetaMask wallet, reload the Editor on the same parcels, or just reload it in the Browser.
// Expected: see v2
// Actual: You will probably see scene v1, because the network save process hasn't completed.

// Suggestion: provide some sort of save-progress indicator that displays until the new version is confirmed as saved.

// Think about a mechanism that will protect other collaborative editor from reloading the old version during that window, too.

Open Loader
Select land (buy it if you don't own it).
Open editor on your land
Place some object in the scene.
Move the Y position of the <a-entity [object] [light] [material]> to 50m (higher in the sky)
Publish scene.
Close editor
Reopen Editor from the same land selection
// expected: the light remains where you put it
// actual: the light is back at the default position of 10,10,10

It says:
"The contents can be stored to the IPFS network using the [download] button on the top left corner."

In upper left of Editor is a Save button.
In the upper Right a download button.

What do they do?