nanowallets-guide / nanowallets-json Goto Github PK

Hello! I'm reaching out on behalf of Stack Wallet to request that we be added to your guide. If you aren't familiar, we support both Nano and Banano and are an open-source, self-custody, new-user-friendly and privacy-centered mobile wallet for Android, iOS, and desktop (Windows, Linux, M-series Macs). If you have any questions please feel free to email us at [email protected] or DM us at @stack_wallet on Twitter for additional information. I'll be linking our website and GitHub below as well. Thank you!

Stack Wallet Repo

Official Website

Is there any chance this will receive updates? I remember it being a good comparing tool back then...

The Atomic and Exodus wallets are listed as open source but neither one is. There are some open source libraries on their github but not the wallets themselves.

Also confirmed by these pages:
https://support.exodus.io/article/89-is-exodus-open-source
https://atomicwallet.io/terms-of-service

Relevant part from Atomic ToS: "You are not permitted to redistribute any of Atomic Services, modify any code or use any Atomic content, including images and text, as part of any other software or project of any kind" (section 4). That doesn't quite say source isn't available for reading, but basically people use the term "open source" for FOSS, don't they? And the source is nowhere to be found anyway (I even asked their support).

For the description of "open source" on you readme, "If core parts (core as in handling of funds) of the wallet are open source.", that's a custom definition not mentioned on the web site, and neither Atomic nor Exodus fulfill that definition anyway. You cannot even confirm the wallets are using any of the libraries on github, since the wallet source itself isn't available.

Please do the honest thing and list them as proprietary, because otherwise people have to waste time digging up the truth, like I did.

Proprietary until proven otherwise.

This caveat note should be added about Trust wallet:

Trust wallet does not allow ledger recovery if ledger uses a BIP39 passphrase.

(Note: Nault supports the BIP39 passphrase for ledger recovery)