JOSS paper - suggestions about manif HOT 5 CLOSED

Also, please check what should be linked to the "Archive" link on the left of page 1. It seems that it does not work.

from manif.

Next, I can not find version number so I can not tick "Version: Does the release version given match the GitHub release (branch: joss)?". The bibliograophy cites manif without version, and there are now releases at https://github.com/artivis/manif/releases. I suggest to publish an official release on GitHub with a proper version (see e.g. https://help.github.com/en/articles/creating-releases) and cite that one.

from manif.

Hi @alex-konovalov,
thanks for the review. We will address it as soon as possible.

from manif.

@alex-konovalov, we addressed your remarks as follows,

• wave_geometry references the library associated paper together with the github repository
• boost reference rendering was fixed
• The Achive link is part of the joss paper template, I do not think we have control over this. I believe it will be linked to a valid url once the paper published.
• manif will be released soon after a couple small fixes are made (pull requests opened and pending)

from manif.

Thanks @artivis and @joansola !

from manif.