Building outlines do not contain their holes. about vector-datasource HOT 2 CLOSED

Hi Till -- the inner ring information is encoded in the vector tiles, but the confusion probably arises from how this data is stored natively in OSM. "Proper" GIS polygons have a concept of multiple rings in a single polygon (not multipolygon!), where the first ring is the outer ring, and subsequent rings are inner rings which are "cut out" of the outer one. A multipolygon is a separate concept, for spatially disjoint polygons (each of which can have its own outer and inner rings).

Since OSM only has single-ring "ways", they have no native way of encoding multi-ring polygons, hence they use what they call "multipolygon" relations to encode this information. When this data is imported into postgis with osm2pgsql, those OSM multipolygon relations get converted into multi-ring polygons, or true multipolygons where they do not overlap. Some info in the docs here.

In these vector tiles, those features are exposed as GeoJSON polygons (which can have multiple rings, as in the building example you give) and disjoint multipolygons. You can see that building rendering correctly with inner courtyards here: http://tangrams.github.io/tangram/#mapzen,52.49877546805041,13.397671580314638,17

Hope that helps! I'm going to close this issue but feel free to follow up with any clarifications or issues here. Thanks.

from vector-datasource.

Oh boy. Thanks very much for the explanation. I forgot about them. (It just seems so unsemantic.)

Anyway, glad to hear. Then it's simply a bug in my GeoJSON parser.

from vector-datasource.