SSH key pair about renovate HOT 5 CLOSED

I quite like option 3 because it means one less manual step using the GitHub web interface. i.e. user only needs to generate access token for designated bot account and not also mess with SSH keys if they're not familiar with them.

This would work well for most environments, e.g. the script could look for ~/.ssh/id_rsa.pub` and upload that via GitHub API the first run.

We could perhaps make it fail gracefully or with non-error warning message if the user doesn't want to grant key read/write permissions for the API. In a way then option 1 would be backwards compatible with option 3.

AWS lambda doesn't have the concept of a full user directory with .ssh directory, but it could pull the key pair from a secure S3 prior to run.

from renovate.

Conclusion:

1. Assume we will use ~/.ssh/id_rsa for now and users will manually add that public key to GitHub
2. Add functionality later to attempt adding public key automatically using API

Leaving this issue open for part 2

from renovate.

I realised a problem just now. I was attempting to add my public key (id_rsa.pub) to a bot account I'd set up, but GitHub gives me this error message:

i.e. public keys are used to identify GitHub users, so you can't add it to more than one GitHub account.

This makes me more inclined to generate a custom key pair just for this tool/bot, to avoid any such conflict.

from renovate.

In theory it would be possible to generate a temporary key pair every run, then add it to the GitHub account, then remove it at the end.

One problem of course would be if the program crashes and doesn't remove the key, but GitHub's API lets you give a "title" to each key so we could name it renovate for example and have a first step that deletes it if found.

A second problem might be latency - e.g. does it work instantly once you add it via API, or is there a delay until it's active? This needs to be tested as it would be a problem for the first run of the script regardless.

from renovate.

In that case, the logic would be approximately:

1. Delete "renovate" key if exists
2. Generate temporary key pair
3. Add temporary public key via GitHub API, with title "renovate"
4. [Rest of script]
5. Delete renovate key

from renovate.