On comment submit click, wrong page redirect when there are pingbacks (counted incorrectly) about hueman HOT 5 CLOSED

I'm not experiencing this behaviour on my local site, both with logged-in an non-logged-in user.

from hueman.

Hm - let's say you have it set WordPress to show 10 top-level comments per page. Pingbacks seem to still be seen as top level comments for the comment submit button's redirect count, even if it's a separate list.

• If you have 7 top-level comments, and 4 pingbacks, it redirects to a page-2, which has no comments, just a "previous comments" link
• If you have 16 top-level comments and 4 pingbacks, no issue will be noticed as 16+4=20, no page change there
• If you have 20 comments and 21 pingbacks you will be redirected 2 pages ahead and have to click "previous comments" twice to get back to the list

At least this is how I experience the issue. You can do a test comment on here, where the issue can be noticed:
http://alxmedia.se/themes/hueman/ (plenty of pingbacks)

It uses the same comments template as Hueman.

from hueman.

I think that the $wp_query->comments Object includes the Pingbacks. You can do it better if you use your own comment and pingback Array as that Parameter.
Ressources:
https://codex.wordpress.org/Function_Reference/get_comment_pages_count#Parameters
https://thematictheme.com/2012/06/13/improved-separation-of-comments-and-pingbacks-in-thematic-1-0-1/

I'm working on a Bugfix - I hope that this will work.

from hueman.

Thanks for having a look at this issue! I tested this fix on my site. I wrote the following comment in the comment box: "A friendly reminder: Use the support forums for theme support."

On comment-submit click, I am redirectecd to:
http://alxmedia.se/themes/hueman/comment-page-32/#comment-29278
The accurate link should be:
http://alxmedia.se/themes/hueman/comment-page-23/#comment-29278

It sends me to /comment-page-32/ and have to click "« Older Comments" so many times until I get to /comment-page-23/ which is the actual comments page (due to many pingbacks being counted as parent comments).

So it's not quite fixed, not sure what to do here.

from hueman.

Ok, I will watch it again - if I got time. It confuses me.
You can try to look at the Wordpress Themes Twenty* Don't know how they seperate Comments and Pingbacks.

from hueman.