Feature request: horizontal list about react-virtuoso HOT 22 OPEN

@shoNagai Hello! How do you feel about your feature commits so far?

After trying and implementing react-window, react-virtualized, and react-virtuoso with beautiful-dnd, virtuoso was the one that caused me the least amount of problems but was missing horizontal. 🙏 How far did you get with it? I saw the branch had two commits in it. Thank you!

from react-virtuoso.

@shoNagai need horizontal scroll as well, have you had a chance to create a PR for your testing changes?

from react-virtuoso.

Any progress on horizontal scrolling?

from react-virtuoso.

any updates?

I ended up using react-window instead

from react-virtuoso.

@wibed with an attitude like the one in the comment above yours, I have little faith in the success of a such campaign.

from react-virtuoso.

Correct - I haven't implemented horizontal mode. I think that the code for the horizontal list will be exactly the same, but the component has to accept configuration to take scrollLeft / offsetWidth (vs scrollTop / offsetHeight) into account.

All in all, this is a relatively low complexity capability, but it needs tests, docs, etc. If you are interested in contributing, please let me know.

from react-virtuoso.

@wibed thanks. Maybe, I'll make try to make a pr for this.

Again, great work on the library @petyosi 🙌, found this to be one the best fit for the project, have looked at both react window and tanstack virtual.

Thanks, will try to help in this

from react-virtuoso.

This feature request is the main missing feature.

More people can use the library if horizontal is supported

Please add.

from react-virtuoso.

Thanks to @hipstersmoothie this feature is going to make it. Everyone, please check this implementation - looking for feedback.
https://codesandbox.io/p/sandbox/horizontal-virtuoso-j2xn2q?file=%2Fsrc%2FApp.tsx%3A8%2C5.

The horizontal positioning of the items is not "out of the box", so I chose to do so with inline-block.

from react-virtuoso.

@petyosi I want this feature too.
So I'm still testing it out, but I'll try to implement it.
feature/horizontal-list

from react-virtuoso.

any updates?

from react-virtuoso.

@NawarA - do you want to sponsor the development of the feature? If so, let me know.

from react-virtuoso.

@petyosi What do you mean? Are you asking me to pay you to release the feature?

from react-virtuoso.

@petyosi could you open a gofundme or similar so we can chip in?

from react-virtuoso.

Is this happening?

from react-virtuoso.

Petyosi afaik is not paid to maintain this package, making new features a long endevour. And since he his not making any money your essentially asking him to do work for free. As he has clearly stated, you can sponsor the repo, or make a pr (it is open source after all!). Otherwise the feature has no plans of coming any time soon. no shade on the dev, what he's asking for is entirely fair lmao

from react-virtuoso.

@chazzox I understand that, however I was deciding between react window and this and found out that horizontal lists are not supported, hence wanted to know if there are plans for this, if not I'll pick up some other library.

I am in no way forcing petyosi to build something, I just need information whether this is happening or not and on the basis of that I have to make a call for my project.

It's a great library and I was leaning into using it but then found out about horizontal lists.

from react-virtuoso.

@mihir-karbelkar-wiz its not.

from react-virtuoso.

Just here to support the need of this feature. Only if possible of course.

Mui mention this package in their documentation so I am guessing the feature requests (or maybe feature demands is more accurate) got grown much more.

Thank you.

from react-virtuoso.

@ItamarSmirra it's great that you are going to support this feature. Should I expect a sponsorship or PR from you? Let me know, thank you.

from react-virtuoso.

@petyosi I'm interested in sponsoring this work. If I were to sponsor you say for 2-3 months could we get this feature?

from react-virtuoso.

update: the sponsorship of this feature has been retracted. If someone is interested in having this published, contact me.

from react-virtuoso.