Prioritise higher index preferred rules about antlr4-c3 HOT 5 OPEN

I've solved this issue in my code by reversing the order like @kapinter-atl suggested. However in some cases I do prefer getting the parent so I've added "rulePriorities" configuration which I use after the fact to traverse the parents and if there is a parent with a higher priority I return that.

Most of the time however, the "wanted-rules" I set are not low level like "identifier", I would create a specific rule like: field_name: IDENTIFIER; and set the target rule to "field_name". This works well with the reverse direction.

from antlr4-c3.

Yes, this was a deliberate decision. Otherwise you would constantly get "low level" tokens, like identifier where you want to get e.g. class name (which consists of identifiers). That might not always lead to the desired result, but I see no other approach without compromising the original idea.

from antlr4-c3.

The class name example is interesting and I'd hope you'd be able to avoid those low level tokens by creating a rule to alias identifier and use that as a preferred rule where necessary. But it seems that regardless of high -> low or low -> high it would be difficult to accomodate both use cases.
Perhaps more granular configuration is needed as @jasonf20 mentioned. Either some form of rulePriorities or being able to specify what direction you want preferred rules to be analysed.

from antlr4-c3.

Yes, that's indeed an interesting idea. Making that switchable should give everyone the best results.

from antlr4-c3.

Hi @mike-lischke I have a related use case. I capture a low-level rule in my preferred rules, but I need to know all the rule lists it can appear within. I could refactor my grammar to duplicate the common rules in the hierarchy, giving them different names, so I can collect low-level-rule, low-level-rule-copy1, low-level-rule-copy2, etc, however I would prefer not doing that for maintenance reasons. Would you be open to a PR that adds a new configuration (e.g. collectAllPreferredRuleLists) that controls whether for each preferred rule a single ruleList or all possible ruleList's are returned? It could be done in a backwards-compatible fashion by adding an optional additionalRuleList field of CandidateRule.

This does intersect with some use cases of the translateRulesTopDown setting. I suspect some people would be leaving translateRulesTopDown = true today because that allows them to capture all possible higher level preferred rules despite them sharing a common lower-level preferred rule descendent. In the future we might want to deprecate that setting in favor of always translating the rules bottom up, and to still be able to capture all desired higher-level rules they could use this collectAllPreferredRuleLists setting and add code to their application to analyze the rule lists to find whether the preferred rule has the desired higher-level rule in one of the possible rule lists.

from antlr4-c3.