How: `scene.append_with_opacity(scene)` about vello HOT 3 CLOSED

What you want here is push_layer, and in particular where you get to specify the alpha. You do need to supply a clip shape, which in many cases can be the axis aligned bounding box enclosing the content.

If you just want an alpha group, then you should use Mix::Normal and Compose::SrcOver. That's not the default, which I can see can cause problems.

A couple of notes. If you nest these deeply (more than 4) you might run into problems with the current implementation, as we don't fully implement the overflow of the blend stack. That's a bug though and if it becomes important we can prioritize it.

Also, I've explored making the clip shape optional. The stack monoid paper explains how to compute blend bounding boxes and there is prototype code there. However, wiring it all up is nontrivial. It's probably easiest to have the application provide the clip shape for now.

from vello.

I think we should close this issue, with this answer. We could open a new issue for making the clip shape optional, if needed.

from vello.

I implemented this for SVG/Lottie using a fullsize rect as mentioned.

The problem is that raw scenes dont have a size, and therefore no clip shape that makes sense.
But I'd maybe argue if a user is rendering a raw scene with bevy_vello, they can apply opacity how they want themselves.

from vello.