Comments (19)
jschueller
commented on June 30, 2024
1
It could be that combining intel fortran and visual studio compiler is not possible because linker arguments and abi are not compatible, could you try using the intel C compiler instead ? It would involve changing the cmake generator, for example Ninja.
from prima.
amontoison
commented on June 30, 2024
1
On Windows, we need an import library (.lib) if we want to compile with MSVC.
Some cross-compilers like MinGW are smart enough to not require it.
I suggest to try the icc compiler with the CMake flag -DCMAKE_C_COMPILER=icc.
from prima.
dbischof90
commented on June 30, 2024
1
Okay, apologies, then I was indeed at the right address first. The tests did also help initially to figure out how to set up the Intel compiler for me, they also act as some form of documentation in the ideal case, which the maintainers achieved here very well so far.
Having well-documented examples and tests on how to create shared libraries will help other people write diverse language wrappers too and the more systems they can target, the more coverage you can generate.
from prima.
jschueller
commented on June 30, 2024
1
yes, its the default mode, but we didnt test MS visual C / intel fortran combination
from prima.
jschueller
commented on June 30, 2024
isnt that a dynamic lib ?
Installing: C:/MyWS/prima/install/bin/primac.dll
from prima.
dbischof90
commented on June 30, 2024
Correct - but it's empty (0B). If you check the middle of the log you'll see that the part you contributed somehow doesn't compile because of "unknown options (/fpp etc) and "unresolved external symbols" (German translation).
Just out of the blue, while my C is a bit rusty, is it possible that the header file is not found during the linking? The Fortran part seems to work out fine.
from prima.
jschueller
commented on June 30, 2024
weird, I dont see the fortran sources of primac being compiled, only prima.c, and also fortran flags seem incorrectly being passed to the cl C compiler: "/heap-arrays" wird ignoriert.
from prima.
dbischof90
commented on June 30, 2024
True. So the Fortran part seems to work so the differences between the make files could be it.
@zaikunzhang I think you wrote the Fortran part - any ideas? You wrote a note in the Makefile that the exports must be treated differently, could that be something?
Not sure how to debug this, I'd be very thankful for some explicit help 😄 no real experience with CMake unfortunately.
from prima.
zaikunzhang
commented on June 30, 2024
True. So the Fortran part seems to work so the differences between the make files could be it.
@zaikunzhang I think you wrote the Fortran part - any ideas? You wrote a note in the Makefile that the exports must be treated differently, could that be something?
Not sure how to debug this, I'd be very thankful for some explicit help 😄 no real experience with CMake unfortunately.
Hi @dbischof90 , the CMake building system was by @jschueller, except that I made some minor revisions to the comments, only wordings. I am ignorant about CMake. I hope @jschueller will figure out the problem. Thank you.
BTW, this may be a reminder that we should test both the shared and the static libraries in the CI. Do we have that already?
In my experience, it has always been a good idea to make as many tests as possible, including some "unnecessary" tests (see the discussion on tests). Many problems and bugs have been spotted and fixed thanks to some "stupid" tests. If we don't have some tests like "oh that test, it is not needed, because I know it will pass", we are not testing sufficiently. That kind of test is more likely to surprise me, due to my limited knowledge, or because compilers/platforms do not behave as expected or even incorrectly (compilers have bugs, and PRIMA has revealed MANY). Maybe we are in such a situation again.
Thanks.
from prima.
dbischof90
commented on June 30, 2024
So, I got a little further.
I installed the Intel oneAPI C and Fortran compilers and, after setting the environment variables correctly (by using the "oneAPI command prompt", which sets the variables and paths accordingly (Windows...)) I could build at least.
The first observation is that on Windows, according to https://www.intel.com/content/www/us/en/docs/dpcpp-cpp-compiler/developer-guide-reference/2023-0/use-cmake-with-the-compiler.html, the only supported build tool for the oneAPI Intel compiler is Ninja. I installed that too and then got
:: initializing oneAPI environment...
Initializing Visual Studio command-line environment...
Visual Studio version 16.11.28 environment configured.
"C:\Program Files (x86)\Microsoft Visual Studio\2019\Professional\"
Visual Studio command-line environment initialized for: 'x64'
: compiler -- latest
: debugger -- latest
: dev-utilities -- latest
: mpi -- latest
: tbb -- latest
:: oneAPI environment initialized ::
C:\Program Files (x86)\Intel\oneAPI>cd C:\MyWS\prima
C:\MyWS\prima>cmake -DCMAKE_INSTALL_PREFIX=install -GNinja -DBUILD_SHARED_LIBS=1 -B build -S .
-- The Fortran compiler identification is IntelLLVM 2023.2.0 with MSVC-like command-line
-- Detecting Fortran compiler ABI info
-- Detecting Fortran compiler ABI info - done
-- Check for working Fortran compiler: C:/Program Files (x86)/Intel/oneAPI/compiler/latest/windows/bin/ifx.exe - skipped
-- Assuming Intel symbol mangling
-- The C compiler identification is IntelLLVM 2023.2.0 with MSVC-like command-line
-- Detecting C compiler ABI info
-- Detecting C compiler ABI info - done
-- Check for working C compiler: C:/Program Files (x86)/Intel/oneAPI/compiler/latest/windows/bin/icx.exe - skipped
-- Detecting C compile features
-- Detecting C compile features - done
-- Configuring done (2.7s)
-- Generating done (0.1s)
-- Build files have been written to: C:/MyWS/prima/build
C:\MyWS\prima>cmake --build build --target install
[65/128] Building Fortran object fortran\CMakeFiles\primaf.dir\common\consts.F90.obj
fortran\CMakeFiles\primaf.dir\common\C:\MyWS\prima\fortran\common\ppf.h(158): warning #5117: Bad # preprocessor line
# 2 "fortran\CMakeFiles\primaf.dir\common\C:\MyWS\prima\fortran\common\consts.F90" 2
------------------------------------------------------------------------------------^
[67/128] Building Fortran object fortran\CMakeFiles\primaf.dir\common\huge.F90.obj
fortran\CMakeFiles\primaf.dir\common\C:\MyWS\prima\fortran\common\ppf.h(158): warning #5117: Bad # preprocessor line
# 2 "fortran\CMakeFiles\primaf.dir\common\C:\MyWS\prima\fortran\common\huge.F90" 2
----------------------------------------------------------------------------------^
[70/128] Building Fortran object fortran\CMakeFiles\primaf.dir\common\inf.F90.obj
fortran\CMakeFiles\primaf.dir\common\C:\MyWS\prima\fortran\common\ppf.h(158): warning #5117: Bad # preprocessor line
# 2 "fortran\CMakeFiles\primaf.dir\common\C:\MyWS\prima\fortran\common\inf.F90" 2
---------------------------------------------------------------------------------^
[71/128] Building Fortran object fortran\CMakeFiles\primaf.dir\common\debug.F90.obj
fortran\CMakeFiles\primaf.dir\common\C:\MyWS\prima\fortran\common\ppf.h(158): warning #5117: Bad # preprocessor line
# 2 "fortran\CMakeFiles\primaf.dir\common\C:\MyWS\prima\fortran\common\debug.F90" 2
-----------------------------------------------------------------------------------^
[72/128] Building Fortran object fortran\CMakeFiles\primaf.dir\common\infnan.F90.obj
fortran\CMakeFiles\primaf.dir\common\C:\MyWS\prima\fortran\common\ppf.h(158): warning #5117: Bad # preprocessor line
# 2 "fortran\CMakeFiles\primaf.dir\common\C:\MyWS\prima\fortran\common\infnan.F90" 2
------------------------------------------------------------------------------------^
[76/128] Building Fortran object fortran\CMakeFiles\primaf.dir\common\memory.F90.obj
fortran\CMakeFiles\primaf.dir\common\C:\MyWS\prima\fortran\common\ppf.h(158): warning #5117: Bad # preprocessor line
# 2 "fortran\CMakeFiles\primaf.dir\common\C:\MyWS\prima\fortran\common\memory.F90" 2
------------------------------------------------------------------------------------^
[127/128] Install the project...
-- Install configuration: "Release"
-- Installing: C:/MyWS/prima/install/lib/primaf.lib
-- Installing: C:/MyWS/prima/install/bin/primaf.dll
-- Installing: C:/MyWS/prima/install/lib/primac.lib
-- Installing: C:/MyWS/prima/install/bin/primac.dll
-- Installing: C:/MyWS/prima/install/lib/cmake/prima/prima-targets.cmake
-- Installing: C:/MyWS/prima/install/lib/cmake/prima/prima-targets-release.cmake
-- Installing: C:/MyWS/prima/install/lib/cmake/prima/prima-config.cmake
-- Installing: C:/MyWS/prima/install/lib/cmake/prima/prima-config-version.cmake
-- Installing: C:/MyWS/prima/install/include/prima/mod
-- Installing: C:/MyWS/prima/install/include/prima/mod/bobyqa_mod.mod
-- Installing: C:/MyWS/prima/install/include/prima/mod/bobyqb_mod.mod
-- Installing: C:/MyWS/prima/install/include/prima/mod/checkexit_mod.mod
-- Installing: C:/MyWS/prima/install/include/prima/mod/cobyla_mod.mod
-- Installing: C:/MyWS/prima/install/include/prima/mod/cobylb_mod.mod
-- Installing: C:/MyWS/prima/install/include/prima/mod/consts_mod.mod
-- Installing: C:/MyWS/prima/install/include/prima/mod/debug_mod.mod
-- Installing: C:/MyWS/prima/install/include/prima/mod/evaluate_mod.mod
-- Installing: C:/MyWS/prima/install/include/prima/mod/fprint_mod.mod
-- Installing: C:/MyWS/prima/install/include/prima/mod/geometry_bobyqa_mod.mod
-- Installing: C:/MyWS/prima/install/include/prima/mod/geometry_cobyla_mod.mod
-- Installing: C:/MyWS/prima/install/include/prima/mod/geometry_lincoa_mod.mod
-- Installing: C:/MyWS/prima/install/include/prima/mod/geometry_newuoa_mod.mod
-- Installing: C:/MyWS/prima/install/include/prima/mod/geometry_uobyqa_mod.mod
-- Installing: C:/MyWS/prima/install/include/prima/mod/getact_mod.mod
-- Installing: C:/MyWS/prima/install/include/prima/mod/history_mod.mod
-- Installing: C:/MyWS/prima/install/include/prima/mod/huge_mod.mod
-- Installing: C:/MyWS/prima/install/include/prima/mod/infnan_mod.mod
-- Installing: C:/MyWS/prima/install/include/prima/mod/infos_mod.mod
-- Installing: C:/MyWS/prima/install/include/prima/mod/inf_mod.mod
-- Installing: C:/MyWS/prima/install/include/prima/mod/initialize_bobyqa_mod.mod
-- Installing: C:/MyWS/prima/install/include/prima/mod/initialize_cobyla_mod.mod
-- Installing: C:/MyWS/prima/install/include/prima/mod/initialize_lincoa_mod.mod
-- Installing: C:/MyWS/prima/install/include/prima/mod/initialize_newuoa_mod.mod
-- Installing: C:/MyWS/prima/install/include/prima/mod/initialize_uobyqa_mod.mod
-- Installing: C:/MyWS/prima/install/include/prima/mod/linalg_mod.mod
-- Installing: C:/MyWS/prima/install/include/prima/mod/lincoa_mod.mod
-- Installing: C:/MyWS/prima/install/include/prima/mod/lincob_mod.mod
-- Installing: C:/MyWS/prima/install/include/prima/mod/memory_mod.mod
-- Installing: C:/MyWS/prima/install/include/prima/mod/message_mod.mod
-- Installing: C:/MyWS/prima/install/include/prima/mod/newuoa_mod.mod
-- Installing: C:/MyWS/prima/install/include/prima/mod/newuob_mod.mod
-- Installing: C:/MyWS/prima/install/include/prima/mod/pintrf_mod.mod
-- Installing: C:/MyWS/prima/install/include/prima/mod/powalg_mod.mod
-- Installing: C:/MyWS/prima/install/include/prima/mod/preproc_mod.mod
-- Installing: C:/MyWS/prima/install/include/prima/mod/ratio_mod.mod
-- Installing: C:/MyWS/prima/install/include/prima/mod/redrho_mod.mod
-- Installing: C:/MyWS/prima/install/include/prima/mod/rescue_mod.mod
-- Installing: C:/MyWS/prima/install/include/prima/mod/selectx_mod.mod
-- Installing: C:/MyWS/prima/install/include/prima/mod/shiftbase_mod.mod
-- Installing: C:/MyWS/prima/install/include/prima/mod/string_mod.mod
-- Installing: C:/MyWS/prima/install/include/prima/mod/trustregion_bobyqa_mod.mod
-- Installing: C:/MyWS/prima/install/include/prima/mod/trustregion_cobyla_mod.mod
-- Installing: C:/MyWS/prima/install/include/prima/mod/trustregion_lincoa_mod.mod
-- Installing: C:/MyWS/prima/install/include/prima/mod/trustregion_newuoa_mod.mod
-- Installing: C:/MyWS/prima/install/include/prima/mod/trustregion_uobyqa_mod.mod
-- Installing: C:/MyWS/prima/install/include/prima/mod/univar_mod.mod
-- Installing: C:/MyWS/prima/install/include/prima/mod/uobyqa_mod.mod
-- Installing: C:/MyWS/prima/install/include/prima/mod/uobyqb_mod.mod
-- Installing: C:/MyWS/prima/install/include/prima/mod/update_bobyqa_mod.mod
-- Installing: C:/MyWS/prima/install/include/prima/mod/update_cobyla_mod.mod
-- Installing: C:/MyWS/prima/install/include/prima/mod/update_lincoa_mod.mod
-- Installing: C:/MyWS/prima/install/include/prima/mod/update_newuoa_mod.mod
-- Installing: C:/MyWS/prima/install/include/prima/mod/update_uobyqa_mod.mod
-- Installing: C:/MyWS/prima/install/include/prima/mod/xinbd_mod.mod
-- Installing: C:/MyWS/prima/install/include/prima/prima.hThat gave me (besides some warnings) two non-empty .dll files which I however still can't load (tried in Python just to see if all was good). Upon further inspection with DependencyWalker, the following situation emerged:
So it seems that
- for the Intel compiler, some of the FORTRAN flags might not be working. However, the DLL seems to be fine otherwise.
- compiling the C wrapper seems to lead to missing dependency and there seems to be at least one circular dependency.
Not so easy apparently.
from prima.
jschueller
commented on June 30, 2024
It looks fine, you can try to compile and run the tests to be sure
from prima.
dbischof90
commented on June 30, 2024
It looks fine, you can try to compile and run the tests to be sure
So I can now at least confirm that your example successfully compiles! Starting from a "clean slate":
C:\MyWS\prima>cmake -DCMAKE_INSTALL_PREFIX=install -GNinja -DBUILD_SHARED_LIBS=OFF -B build -S .
-- The Fortran compiler identification is IntelLLVM 2023.2.0 with MSVC-like command-line
-- Detecting Fortran compiler ABI info
-- Detecting Fortran compiler ABI info - done
-- Check for working Fortran compiler: C:/Program Files (x86)/Intel/oneAPI/compiler/latest/windows/bin/ifx.exe - skipped
-- The C compiler identification is IntelLLVM 2023.2.0 with MSVC-like command-line
-- Detecting C compiler ABI info
-- Detecting C compiler ABI info - done
-- Check for working C compiler: C:/Program Files (x86)/Intel/oneAPI/compiler/latest/windows/bin/icx.exe - skipped
-- Detecting C compile features
-- Detecting C compile features - done
-- Configuring done (2.9s)
-- Generating done (0.0s)
-- Build files have been written to: C:/MyWS/prima/build
C:\MyWS\prima>cmake --build build --target install
[65/128] Building Fortran object fortran\CMakeFiles\primaf.dir\common\consts.F90.obj
fortran\CMakeFiles\primaf.dir\common\C:\MyWS\prima\fortran\common\ppf.h(158): warning #5117: Bad # preprocessor line
# 2 "fortran\CMakeFiles\primaf.dir\common\C:\MyWS\prima\fortran\common\consts.F90" 2
------------------------------------------------------------------------------------^
[67/128] Building Fortran object fortran\CMakeFiles\primaf.dir\common\huge.F90.obj
fortran\CMakeFiles\primaf.dir\common\C:\MyWS\prima\fortran\common\ppf.h(158): warning #5117: Bad # preprocessor line
# 2 "fortran\CMakeFiles\primaf.dir\common\C:\MyWS\prima\fortran\common\huge.F90" 2
----------------------------------------------------------------------------------^
[70/128] Building Fortran object fortran\CMakeFiles\primaf.dir\common\inf.F90.obj
fortran\CMakeFiles\primaf.dir\common\C:\MyWS\prima\fortran\common\ppf.h(158): warning #5117: Bad # preprocessor line
# 2 "fortran\CMakeFiles\primaf.dir\common\C:\MyWS\prima\fortran\common\inf.F90" 2
---------------------------------------------------------------------------------^
[71/128] Building Fortran object fortran\CMakeFiles\primaf.dir\common\debug.F90.obj
fortran\CMakeFiles\primaf.dir\common\C:\MyWS\prima\fortran\common\ppf.h(158): warning #5117: Bad # preprocessor line
# 2 "fortran\CMakeFiles\primaf.dir\common\C:\MyWS\prima\fortran\common\debug.F90" 2
-----------------------------------------------------------------------------------^
[72/128] Building Fortran object fortran\CMakeFiles\primaf.dir\common\infnan.F90.obj
fortran\CMakeFiles\primaf.dir\common\C:\MyWS\prima\fortran\common\ppf.h(158): warning #5117: Bad # preprocessor line
# 2 "fortran\CMakeFiles\primaf.dir\common\C:\MyWS\prima\fortran\common\infnan.F90" 2
------------------------------------------------------------------------------------^
[76/128] Building Fortran object fortran\CMakeFiles\primaf.dir\common\memory.F90.obj
fortran\CMakeFiles\primaf.dir\common\C:\MyWS\prima\fortran\common\ppf.h(158): warning #5117: Bad # preprocessor line
# 2 "fortran\CMakeFiles\primaf.dir\common\C:\MyWS\prima\fortran\common\memory.F90" 2
------------------------------------------------------------------------------------^
[127/128] Install the project...-- Install configuration: "Release"
-- Installing: C:/MyWS/prima/install/lib/primaf.lib
-- Installing: C:/MyWS/prima/install/lib/primac.lib
-- Installing: C:/MyWS/prima/install/lib/cmake/prima/prima-targets.cmake
-- Installing: C:/MyWS/prima/install/lib/cmake/prima/prima-targets-release.cmake
-- Installing: C:/MyWS/prima/install/lib/cmake/prima/prima-config.cmake
-- Installing: C:/MyWS/prima/install/lib/cmake/prima/prima-config-version.cmake
-- Installing: C:/MyWS/prima/install/include/prima/mod
-- Installing: C:/MyWS/prima/install/include/prima/mod/bobyqa_mod.mod
-- Installing: C:/MyWS/prima/install/include/prima/mod/bobyqb_mod.mod
-- Installing: C:/MyWS/prima/install/include/prima/mod/checkexit_mod.mod
-- Installing: C:/MyWS/prima/install/include/prima/mod/cobyla_mod.mod
-- Installing: C:/MyWS/prima/install/include/prima/mod/cobylb_mod.mod
-- Installing: C:/MyWS/prima/install/include/prima/mod/consts_mod.mod
-- Installing: C:/MyWS/prima/install/include/prima/mod/debug_mod.mod
-- Installing: C:/MyWS/prima/install/include/prima/mod/evaluate_mod.mod
-- Installing: C:/MyWS/prima/install/include/prima/mod/fprint_mod.mod
-- Installing: C:/MyWS/prima/install/include/prima/mod/geometry_bobyqa_mod.mod
-- Installing: C:/MyWS/prima/install/include/prima/mod/geometry_cobyla_mod.mod
-- Installing: C:/MyWS/prima/install/include/prima/mod/geometry_lincoa_mod.mod
-- Installing: C:/MyWS/prima/install/include/prima/mod/geometry_newuoa_mod.mod
-- Installing: C:/MyWS/prima/install/include/prima/mod/geometry_uobyqa_mod.mod
-- Installing: C:/MyWS/prima/install/include/prima/mod/getact_mod.mod
-- Installing: C:/MyWS/prima/install/include/prima/mod/history_mod.mod
-- Installing: C:/MyWS/prima/install/include/prima/mod/huge_mod.mod
-- Installing: C:/MyWS/prima/install/include/prima/mod/infnan_mod.mod
-- Installing: C:/MyWS/prima/install/include/prima/mod/infos_mod.mod
-- Installing: C:/MyWS/prima/install/include/prima/mod/inf_mod.mod
-- Installing: C:/MyWS/prima/install/include/prima/mod/initialize_bobyqa_mod.mod
-- Installing: C:/MyWS/prima/install/include/prima/mod/initialize_cobyla_mod.mod
-- Installing: C:/MyWS/prima/install/include/prima/mod/initialize_lincoa_mod.mod
-- Installing: C:/MyWS/prima/install/include/prima/mod/initialize_newuoa_mod.mod
-- Installing: C:/MyWS/prima/install/include/prima/mod/initialize_uobyqa_mod.mod
-- Installing: C:/MyWS/prima/install/include/prima/mod/linalg_mod.mod
-- Installing: C:/MyWS/prima/install/include/prima/mod/lincoa_mod.mod
-- Installing: C:/MyWS/prima/install/include/prima/mod/lincob_mod.mod
-- Installing: C:/MyWS/prima/install/include/prima/mod/memory_mod.mod
-- Installing: C:/MyWS/prima/install/include/prima/mod/message_mod.mod
-- Installing: C:/MyWS/prima/install/include/prima/mod/newuoa_mod.mod
-- Installing: C:/MyWS/prima/install/include/prima/mod/newuob_mod.mod
-- Installing: C:/MyWS/prima/install/include/prima/mod/pintrf_mod.mod
-- Installing: C:/MyWS/prima/install/include/prima/mod/powalg_mod.mod
-- Installing: C:/MyWS/prima/install/include/prima/mod/preproc_mod.mod
-- Installing: C:/MyWS/prima/install/include/prima/mod/ratio_mod.mod
-- Installing: C:/MyWS/prima/install/include/prima/mod/redrho_mod.mod
-- Installing: C:/MyWS/prima/install/include/prima/mod/rescue_mod.mod
-- Installing: C:/MyWS/prima/install/include/prima/mod/selectx_mod.mod
-- Installing: C:/MyWS/prima/install/include/prima/mod/shiftbase_mod.mod
-- Installing: C:/MyWS/prima/install/include/prima/mod/string_mod.mod
-- Installing: C:/MyWS/prima/install/include/prima/mod/trustregion_bobyqa_mod.mod
-- Installing: C:/MyWS/prima/install/include/prima/mod/trustregion_cobyla_mod.mod
-- Installing: C:/MyWS/prima/install/include/prima/mod/trustregion_lincoa_mod.mod
-- Installing: C:/MyWS/prima/install/include/prima/mod/trustregion_newuoa_mod.mod
-- Installing: C:/MyWS/prima/install/include/prima/mod/trustregion_uobyqa_mod.mod
-- Installing: C:/MyWS/prima/install/include/prima/mod/univar_mod.mod
-- Installing: C:/MyWS/prima/install/include/prima/mod/uobyqa_mod.mod
-- Installing: C:/MyWS/prima/install/include/prima/mod/uobyqb_mod.mod
-- Installing: C:/MyWS/prima/install/include/prima/mod/update_bobyqa_mod.mod
-- Installing: C:/MyWS/prima/install/include/prima/mod/update_cobyla_mod.mod
-- Installing: C:/MyWS/prima/install/include/prima/mod/update_lincoa_mod.mod
-- Installing: C:/MyWS/prima/install/include/prima/mod/update_newuoa_mod.mod
-- Installing: C:/MyWS/prima/install/include/prima/mod/update_uobyqa_mod.mod
-- Installing: C:/MyWS/prima/install/include/prima/mod/xinbd_mod.mod
-- Installing: C:/MyWS/prima/install/include/prima/prima.h
C:\MyWS\prima>cd c/examples/cobyla
C:\MyWS\prima\c\examples\cobyla>cmake -S . -B build -DCMAKE_INSTALL_PREFIX=install -DPRIMA_DIR=./../../../install/lib/cmake/prima/ -GNinja
-- The C compiler identification is IntelLLVM 2023.2.0 with MSVC-like command-line
-- Detecting C compiler ABI info
-- Detecting C compiler ABI info - done
-- Check for working C compiler: C:/Program Files (x86)/Intel/oneAPI/compiler/latest/windows/bin/icx.exe - skipped
-- Detecting C compile features
-- Detecting C compile features - done
-- Configuring done (1.4s)
-- Generating done (0.0s)
-- Build files have been written to: C:/MyWS/prima/c/examples/cobyla/build
C:\MyWS\prima\c\examples\cobyla>cmake --build build --target install
[2/3] Install the project...-- Install configuration: "Debug"
-- Installing: C:/MyWS/prima/c/examples/cobyla/install/bin/cobyla_example.exe
C:\MyWS\prima\c\examples\cobyla>C:/MyWS/prima/c/examples/cobyla/install/bin/cobyla_example.exe
Return from COBYLA because the trust region radius reaches its lower bound.
Number of function values = 35 Least value of F = -9.500855780525992E+000 Constraint violation = 0.000000000000000E+000
The corresponding X is: 2.990120684861312E+000 1.992427939779597E+000
The constraint value is:
-8.990120684861312E+000 -7.992427939779597E+000 -3.009879315138688E+000 -4.007572060220403E+000
-1.009879315138688E+000 -1.007572060220403E+000 -5.017451375359091E+000 -8.940919475015008E-002
x*={2.99012, 1.99243} f*=-9.50086 cstrv=0 nlconstr=-0.0894092 rc=0 msg='Trust region radius reaches its lower bound' evals=35Note that I put -GNinja -DBUILD_SHARED_LIBS=OFF at the very top (in accordance to the documentation). So I can in fact compile now and have the toolchain figured out, that's part of the solution.
My goal now is to make this accessible from C#. Hence if I put -GNinja -DBUILD_SHARED_LIBS=1 and leave out the test part I would expect to get DLLs which I can access from dotnet - here that seems to be not there yet. What am I missing here?
from prima.
jschueller
commented on June 30, 2024
show us the logs
from prima.
dbischof90
commented on June 30, 2024
Building with
C:\MyWS\prima>cmake -DCMAKE_INSTALL_PREFIX=install -GNinja -DBUILD_SHARED_LIBS=1 -B build -S .
-- The Fortran compiler identification is IntelLLVM 2023.2.0 with MSVC-like command-line
-- Detecting Fortran compiler ABI info
-- Detecting Fortran compiler ABI info - done
-- Check for working Fortran compiler: C:/Program Files (x86)/Intel/oneAPI/compiler/latest/windows/bin/ifx.exe - skipped
-- Assuming Intel symbol mangling
-- The C compiler identification is IntelLLVM 2023.2.0 with MSVC-like command-line
-- Detecting C compiler ABI info
-- Detecting C compiler ABI info - done
-- Check for working C compiler: C:/Program Files (x86)/Intel/oneAPI/compiler/latest/windows/bin/icx.exe - skipped
-- Detecting C compile features
-- Detecting C compile features - done
-- Configuring done (2.7s)
-- Generating done (0.0s)
-- Build files have been written to: C:/MyWS/prima/build
C:\MyWS\prima>cmake --build build --target install
[65/128] Building Fortran object fortran\CMakeFiles\primaf.dir\common\consts.F90.obj
fortran\CMakeFiles\primaf.dir\common\C:\MyWS\prima\fortran\common\ppf.h(158): warning #5117: Bad # preprocessor line
# 2 "fortran\CMakeFiles\primaf.dir\common\C:\MyWS\prima\fortran\common\consts.F90" 2
------------------------------------------------------------------------------------^
[68/128] Building Fortran object fortran\CMakeFiles\primaf.dir\common\huge.F90.obj
fortran\CMakeFiles\primaf.dir\common\C:\MyWS\prima\fortran\common\ppf.h(158): warning #5117: Bad # preprocessor line
# 2 "fortran\CMakeFiles\primaf.dir\common\C:\MyWS\prima\fortran\common\huge.F90" 2
----------------------------------------------------------------------------------^
[70/128] Building Fortran object fortran\CMakeFiles\primaf.dir\common\inf.F90.obj
fortran\CMakeFiles\primaf.dir\common\C:\MyWS\prima\fortran\common\ppf.h(158): warning #5117: Bad # preprocessor line
# 2 "fortran\CMakeFiles\primaf.dir\common\C:\MyWS\prima\fortran\common\inf.F90" 2
---------------------------------------------------------------------------------^
[71/128] Building Fortran object fortran\CMakeFiles\primaf.dir\common\debug.F90.obj
fortran\CMakeFiles\primaf.dir\common\C:\MyWS\prima\fortran\common\ppf.h(158): warning #5117: Bad # preprocessor line
# 2 "fortran\CMakeFiles\primaf.dir\common\C:\MyWS\prima\fortran\common\debug.F90" 2
-----------------------------------------------------------------------------------^
[72/128] Building Fortran object fortran\CMakeFiles\primaf.dir\common\infnan.F90.obj
fortran\CMakeFiles\primaf.dir\common\C:\MyWS\prima\fortran\common\ppf.h(158): warning #5117: Bad # preprocessor line
# 2 "fortran\CMakeFiles\primaf.dir\common\C:\MyWS\prima\fortran\common\infnan.F90" 2
------------------------------------------------------------------------------------^
[76/128] Building Fortran object fortran\CMakeFiles\primaf.dir\common\memory.F90.obj
fortran\CMakeFiles\primaf.dir\common\C:\MyWS\prima\fortran\common\ppf.h(158): warning #5117: Bad # preprocessor line
# 2 "fortran\CMakeFiles\primaf.dir\common\C:\MyWS\prima\fortran\common\memory.F90" 2
------------------------------------------------------------------------------------^
[127/128] Install the project...-- Install configuration: "Release"
-- Installing: C:/MyWS/prima/install/lib/primaf.lib
-- Installing: C:/MyWS/prima/install/bin/primaf.dll
-- Installing: C:/MyWS/prima/install/lib/primac.lib
-- Installing: C:/MyWS/prima/install/bin/primac.dll
-- Installing: C:/MyWS/prima/install/lib/cmake/prima/prima-targets.cmake
-- Installing: C:/MyWS/prima/install/lib/cmake/prima/prima-targets-release.cmake
-- Installing: C:/MyWS/prima/install/lib/cmake/prima/prima-config.cmake
-- Installing: C:/MyWS/prima/install/lib/cmake/prima/prima-config-version.cmake
-- Installing: C:/MyWS/prima/install/include/prima/mod
-- Installing: C:/MyWS/prima/install/include/prima/mod/bobyqa_mod.mod
-- Installing: C:/MyWS/prima/install/include/prima/mod/bobyqb_mod.mod
-- Installing: C:/MyWS/prima/install/include/prima/mod/checkexit_mod.mod
-- Installing: C:/MyWS/prima/install/include/prima/mod/cobyla_mod.mod
-- Installing: C:/MyWS/prima/install/include/prima/mod/cobylb_mod.mod
-- Installing: C:/MyWS/prima/install/include/prima/mod/consts_mod.mod
-- Installing: C:/MyWS/prima/install/include/prima/mod/debug_mod.mod
-- Installing: C:/MyWS/prima/install/include/prima/mod/evaluate_mod.mod
-- Installing: C:/MyWS/prima/install/include/prima/mod/fprint_mod.mod
-- Installing: C:/MyWS/prima/install/include/prima/mod/geometry_bobyqa_mod.mod
-- Installing: C:/MyWS/prima/install/include/prima/mod/geometry_cobyla_mod.mod
-- Installing: C:/MyWS/prima/install/include/prima/mod/geometry_lincoa_mod.mod
-- Installing: C:/MyWS/prima/install/include/prima/mod/geometry_newuoa_mod.mod
-- Installing: C:/MyWS/prima/install/include/prima/mod/geometry_uobyqa_mod.mod
-- Installing: C:/MyWS/prima/install/include/prima/mod/getact_mod.mod
-- Installing: C:/MyWS/prima/install/include/prima/mod/history_mod.mod
-- Installing: C:/MyWS/prima/install/include/prima/mod/huge_mod.mod
-- Installing: C:/MyWS/prima/install/include/prima/mod/infnan_mod.mod
-- Installing: C:/MyWS/prima/install/include/prima/mod/infos_mod.mod
-- Installing: C:/MyWS/prima/install/include/prima/mod/inf_mod.mod
-- Installing: C:/MyWS/prima/install/include/prima/mod/initialize_bobyqa_mod.mod
-- Installing: C:/MyWS/prima/install/include/prima/mod/initialize_cobyla_mod.mod
-- Installing: C:/MyWS/prima/install/include/prima/mod/initialize_lincoa_mod.mod
-- Installing: C:/MyWS/prima/install/include/prima/mod/initialize_newuoa_mod.mod
-- Installing: C:/MyWS/prima/install/include/prima/mod/initialize_uobyqa_mod.mod
-- Installing: C:/MyWS/prima/install/include/prima/mod/linalg_mod.mod
-- Installing: C:/MyWS/prima/install/include/prima/mod/lincoa_mod.mod
-- Installing: C:/MyWS/prima/install/include/prima/mod/lincob_mod.mod
-- Installing: C:/MyWS/prima/install/include/prima/mod/memory_mod.mod
-- Installing: C:/MyWS/prima/install/include/prima/mod/message_mod.mod
-- Installing: C:/MyWS/prima/install/include/prima/mod/newuoa_mod.mod
-- Installing: C:/MyWS/prima/install/include/prima/mod/newuob_mod.mod
-- Installing: C:/MyWS/prima/install/include/prima/mod/pintrf_mod.mod
-- Installing: C:/MyWS/prima/install/include/prima/mod/powalg_mod.mod
-- Installing: C:/MyWS/prima/install/include/prima/mod/preproc_mod.mod
-- Installing: C:/MyWS/prima/install/include/prima/mod/ratio_mod.mod
-- Installing: C:/MyWS/prima/install/include/prima/mod/redrho_mod.mod
-- Installing: C:/MyWS/prima/install/include/prima/mod/rescue_mod.mod
-- Installing: C:/MyWS/prima/install/include/prima/mod/selectx_mod.mod
-- Installing: C:/MyWS/prima/install/include/prima/mod/shiftbase_mod.mod
-- Installing: C:/MyWS/prima/install/include/prima/mod/string_mod.mod
-- Installing: C:/MyWS/prima/install/include/prima/mod/trustregion_bobyqa_mod.mod
-- Installing: C:/MyWS/prima/install/include/prima/mod/trustregion_cobyla_mod.mod
-- Installing: C:/MyWS/prima/install/include/prima/mod/trustregion_lincoa_mod.mod
-- Installing: C:/MyWS/prima/install/include/prima/mod/trustregion_newuoa_mod.mod
-- Installing: C:/MyWS/prima/install/include/prima/mod/trustregion_uobyqa_mod.mod
-- Installing: C:/MyWS/prima/install/include/prima/mod/univar_mod.mod
-- Installing: C:/MyWS/prima/install/include/prima/mod/uobyqa_mod.mod
-- Installing: C:/MyWS/prima/install/include/prima/mod/uobyqb_mod.mod
-- Installing: C:/MyWS/prima/install/include/prima/mod/update_bobyqa_mod.mod
-- Installing: C:/MyWS/prima/install/include/prima/mod/update_cobyla_mod.mod
-- Installing: C:/MyWS/prima/install/include/prima/mod/update_lincoa_mod.mod
-- Installing: C:/MyWS/prima/install/include/prima/mod/update_newuoa_mod.mod
-- Installing: C:/MyWS/prima/install/include/prima/mod/update_uobyqa_mod.mod
-- Installing: C:/MyWS/prima/install/include/prima/mod/xinbd_mod.mod
-- Installing: C:/MyWS/prima/install/include/prima/prima.h
PS C:\MyWS\prima> cd .\install\bin\
PS C:\MyWS\prima\install\bin> ls
Verzeichnis: C:\MyWS\prima\install\bin
Mode LastWriteTime Length Name
---- ------------- ------ ----
-a---- 25.10.2023 15:20 68096 primac.dll
-a---- 25.10.2023 15:20 1745408 primaf.dllI now just try to load the primac.dll into Python with ctypes.
PS C:\MyWS\prima\install\bin> ipython.exe
Python 3.11.6 (tags/v3.11.6:8b6ee5b, Oct 2 2023, 14:57:12) [MSC v.1935 64 bit (AMD64)]
Type 'copyright', 'credits' or 'license' for more information
IPython 8.16.1 -- An enhanced Interactive Python. Type '?' for help.
In [1]: from ctypes import CDLL
...: import time
In [2]: import os
In [3]: lib = CDLL(os.path.join(os.getcwd(), 'primac.dll'))
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
FileNotFoundError Traceback (most recent call last)
Cell In[3], line 1
----> 1 lib = CDLL(os.path.join(os.getcwd(), 'primac.dll'))
File C:\Program Files\WindowsApps\PythonSoftwareFoundation.Python.3.11_3.11.1776.0_x64__qbz5n2kfra8p0\Lib\ctypes\__init__.py:376, in CDLL.__init__(self, name, mode, handle, use_errno, use_last_error, winmode)
373 self._FuncPtr = _FuncPtr
375 if handle is None:
--> 376 self._handle = _dlopen(self._name, mode)
377 else:
378 self._handle = handle
FileNotFoundError: Could not find module 'C:\MyWS\prima\install\bin\primac.dll' (or one of its dependencies). Try using the full path with constructor syntax.I am definitely in the correct directory, hence my guess was that (or one of its dependencies) is the relevant bit here. That lead me to Dependency Walker mentioned above and the screenshot I posted, which also tells me that a required dependency is not available - almost all of those come out of KERNEL32.DLL as it seems so that does not seem to be linked together correctly. That's however also really just a guess, I only use Windows at work and am currently experimenting there with getting this thing to run.
from prima.
jschueller
commented on June 30, 2024
all prima dlls must be in PATH, try to load primaf.dll first
from prima.
dbischof90
commented on June 30, 2024
Same issue.
In [7]: lib = CDLL(os.path.join(os.getcwd(), 'primaf.dll'))
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
FileNotFoundError Traceback (most recent call last)
Cell In[7], line 1
----> 1 lib = CDLL(os.path.join(os.getcwd(), 'primaf.dll'))
File C:\Program Files\WindowsApps\PythonSoftwareFoundation.Python.3.11_3.11.1776.0_x64__qbz5n2kfra8p0\Lib\ctypes\__init__.py:376, in CDLL.__init__(self, name, mode, handle, use_errno, use_last_error, winmode)
373 self._FuncPtr = _FuncPtr
375 if handle is None:
--> 376 self._handle = _dlopen(self._name, mode)
377 else:
378 self._handle = handle
FileNotFoundError: Could not find module 'C:\MyWS\prima\install\bin\primaf.dll' (or one of its dependencies). Try using the full path with constructor syntax.There's also the option to add DLL directories via https://docs.python.org/3/library/os.html#os.add_dll_directory but that did also not help.
As you see from the output, it's also not really clear to me what's missing either. If you have some more pointers I'm happy to try out things and report back, I'm sure I'm not the only person who'd like to write a custom wrapper on Windows. I'd really prefer that over rewriting it all in C# 🫠
from prima.
zaikunzhang
commented on June 30, 2024
BTW, this may be a reminder that we should test both the shared and the static libraries in the CI. Do we have that already?
Hi @jschueller , have we tested shared libraries in our CI? If not yet, could we maybe add such tests?
I suggest that all possibilities should be tested when introducing a new feature / component. This is nontrivial to do and it takes a lot of time, but it is what I have always tried to achieve during the development of PRIMA (see how many tests PRIMA has now). We should not expect that it can be done in one shot, but we should add new tests when we realize that something is missing.
IMHO, it is normal that tests keep being augmented over time --- it is indeed quite abnormal if they remain the same after being introduced unless the development of the software has terminated.
See also "What kind of tests are sufficient for the porting or translation of PRIMA?".
cc: @emmt @amontoison @nbelakovski @ragonneau @Lht97 @OptHuang
Thanks.
from prima.
zaikunzhang
commented on June 30, 2024
Hi @dbischof90 , @jschueller (many thanks!) has added new CI tests for MS C compiler in combinations with intel fortran compilers: #105 . Could you check whether the configuration of the tests help you to configure the tool chain on your side? Thanks.
from prima.
dbischof90
commented on June 30, 2024
Hi!
So this configuration creates DLLs successfully on my work laptop and judging from the output, those are fine (as in 'not empty'). I could unfortunately not find out how to call them externally (neither from Python nor from C# nor from VB.NET), so I can't say whether or not that works as intended. The errors I'm getting could point to some dependencies missing but that seems to be more a setup issue on my side - I can't tell.
Since I'm not very experienced yet in dotnet nor in windows programming in general, I will put this on the side for now and go with native reimplementation I found online (which I know will be inferior to this setup but I can't get it to run). Judging from the little code that the Julia wrapper consists of, it can't be difficult to write a wrapper library but I'm currently not able to figure out how to do this for Windows systems so this is ultimately unsuccessful for me.
Thank you all for your help in this!
from prima.
Related Issues (20)
- Mexification fails on macOS with Xcode 15 and Intel oneAPI 2023
- The C example on README does not work HOT 1
- cobyla fails CMake test with flang family compilers HOT 1
- Support Function Call Parallelization in MATLAB Interface HOT 1
- Support "OutputFcn" option in MATLAB interface HOT 2
- Enable reverse communication?
- LINCOA doesn't adhere to upper and lower bounds HOT 8
- BOBYQA recursion problem HOT 3
- Rhobeg and rhoend arrays HOT 1
- Improve the scaling
- `PRIMA_INTEGER_KIND` slightly affects the result when compiled with `-Ofast -fno-stack-arrays`
- The behavior of COBYLA is slightly different when `infnan_mod` is broken and the code is compiled with `-Ofast -fno-stack-arrays`
- Should `prima_get_rc_string` be exposed in the C public API?
- CMake test fails with strict diagnostic options for Intel compilers HOT 3
- Add options.ctol to `prima_is_success` HOT 1
- `tracebackqq` in `matlab/mex_gateways/debug.F90` trigers a SEGFAULT when it is called HOT 1
- Get ` PRIMA_PROBLEM_SOLVER_MISMATCH_XXX` back
- Why the versions of OS and gcc in build_python.yml are old? HOT 2
- Python wheel testing fails on macOS 14 (ARM64)
- LINCOA in multiple threads odd results HOT 2
Recommend Projects
-
React
A declarative, efficient, and flexible JavaScript library for building user interfaces.
-
Vue.js
🖖 Vue.js is a progressive, incrementally-adoptable JavaScript framework for building UI on the web.
-
Typescript
TypeScript is a superset of JavaScript that compiles to clean JavaScript output.
-
TensorFlow
An Open Source Machine Learning Framework for Everyone
-
Django
The Web framework for perfectionists with deadlines.
-
Laravel
A PHP framework for web artisans
-
D3
Bring data to life with SVG, Canvas and HTML. 📊📈🎉
-
Recommend Topics
-
javascript
JavaScript (JS) is a lightweight interpreted programming language with first-class functions.
-
web
Some thing interesting about web. New door for the world.
-
server
A server is a program made to process requests and deliver data to clients.
-
Machine learning
Machine learning is a way of modeling and interpreting data that allows a piece of software to respond intelligently.
-
Visualization
Some thing interesting about visualization, use data art
-
Game
Some thing interesting about game, make everyone happy.
Recommend Org
-
Facebook
We are working to build community through open source technology. NB: members must have two-factor auth.
-
Microsoft
Open source projects and samples from Microsoft.
-
Google
Google ❤️ Open Source for everyone.
-
Alibaba
Alibaba Open Source for everyone
-
D3
Data-Driven Documents codes.
-
Tencent
China tencent open source team.
from prima.