cHash issues after TYPO3 upgrade from 7.0 to 7.2 about typoscript_rendering HOT 12 CLOSED

I don't understand that. A wrong cHash should not (and afaik does not) call the hook, not even in TYPO3 6.2 and that is also not intended, because in that case something is wrong and parameters may have been spoofed.

So what exactly is your issue?

from typoscript_rendering.

The problem is that typoscript_rendering does not work in Typo3 7.2. The hook it uses does not get called and the request is redirected to the 404-page.

from typoscript_rendering.

the request is redirected to the 404-page

This is indeed the case when the cHash is wrong. So can you please find out why this is the case? How do you generate the links? Do you use realurl?

from typoscript_rendering.

The extension works perfectly for me in current master btw. …

from typoscript_rendering.

Ok, that's good to know.
realurl is installed, but not yet active
The URIs are generated via the uri.ajaxAction-viewhelper:

{h:uri.ajaxAction(action: 'new', arguments : {format:'json', objektnrextern : '20004-7310'})}

Out of the same extension, plugin and controller (that's why we leave that out).
The links look like:

http://domain/index.php?id=28&tx_typoscriptrendering[context]={%22record%22%3A%22tt_content_113%22%2C%22path%22%3A%22tt_content.list.20.wib24merkzettel_merkzettelplugin%22}&tx_wib24merkzettel_merkzettelplugin[format]=json&tx_wib24merkzettel_merkzettelplugin[objektnrextern]=20004-7310&tx_wib24merkzettel_merkzettelplugin[action]=delete&tx_wib24merkzettel_merkzettelplugin[controller]=Merkzettel

So there is actually no cHash. I just checked typoscript_rendering in another project (EDIT:Typo3 v6.2): there a cHash is attached.

Thank you for looking into that

from typoscript_rendering.

So there is actually no cHash. I just checked typoscript_rendering in another project (Typo3 v7.2): there a cHash is attached.

Yes. We changed that in Extbase that if a link is generated from an uncached action to another uncached action, the cHash is dropped by default.

Now we have an issue here, as typoscript_rendering requires a cHash and there is no possibility to force the URI builder to generate one :-/

We need to fix the core imho

from typoscript_rendering.

Thank you for that insight.
I guess we will just patch \TYPO3\CMS\Extbase\Mvc\Web\Routing\UriBuilder::disableCacheHashForNonCacheableAction() and wait for it to disappear or be configurable in an upcoming Typo3-version.

from typoscript_rendering.

Identified as TYPO3 core issue

from typoscript_rendering.

This is tracked upstream with issue #67097

from typoscript_rendering.

Thank you both!

from typoscript_rendering.

Fix is here: https://review.typo3.org/#/c/39657

from typoscript_rendering.

Works. Many thanks.

from typoscript_rendering.