Option to prevent suspension of tabs that are potentially producing sound about thegreatsuspender HOT 19 CLOSED

Finally! This has now been implemented 👯

from thegreatsuspender.

Available in the chrome webstore in v6.30

from thegreatsuspender.

This might become easier as chrome might be getting a related feature and hopefully API in the near future:

Google Chrome Getting Audio Indicators for Tabs Making Sound

from thegreatsuspender.

I think I might leave this one for now. Adding these sites to the whitelist should be a fairly decent workaround for now.

from thegreatsuspender.

The latest webstore version now has the ability to 'temporarily pause suspension' for a site. If you have a tab open that is playing music and you do not want it to suspend, you can use this option to prevent it from suspending in the background.
I will not be doing any work in future to try and automatically detect tabs that are producing audio.

from thegreatsuspender.

Just to reiterate as this is one of the more commonly requested features. Chrome does not provide developer access to its ability to detect which tab is playing music. Therefore I am unable to include an option to prevent these tabs from suspending.
As an alternative, I have implemented an option in the popup call 'dont suspend for now' which will prevent the current tab from suspending automatically in the background. This can be used to prevent tabs that are playing audio from suspending.
Another alternative is to whitelist the url of the site if you'd like it to always remain unsuspended.

from thegreatsuspender.

Would you consider reopening this ticket if Chrome were to provide the ability to easily detect which tabs were playing audio? Maybe if you got a pull request?

from thegreatsuspender.

Definitely. I would love to have a dedicated option 'dont suspend tabs that are playing audio'.

from thegreatsuspender.

The content script could look for audio/video tags and check !element.paused. There could also be a catch-all setting for Flash/Silverlight as a hack (could still attempt to call !element.paused since the site might be using something like MediaElement.js). If anyone's insane enough to use Java for playback, it appears there's a Java API to detect that too. I don't think it's worth supporting the JS audio API because this is typically used for notification sounds/game sound effects.

It's not a perfect way to do it but considering many major sites are using <audio>/<video> now it might be an acceptable compromise.

Worth also looking at the MuteTab extension's FAQ.

Willing to put in the work for this if you'd like it.

from thegreatsuspender.

@kirb i have checked out mutetab, and it left me with the impression that there's just too much hackery involved in getting this feature working. i could definitely do as you suggested and catch a large percentage of the use-cases, but i'm worried that it would appear to be a buggy feature as it would not work consistently.
You're welcome to have a crack at it, and if it seems to work fairly reliably then i'd consider including it.

from thegreatsuspender.

I think it would be acceptable if there was a "Do not suspend tabs that have audio or video" checkbox that simply checked if the page had any <audio> or <video> tags.

from thegreatsuspender.

I use theses websites to play music: SoundCloud, Mixcloud and YouTube.

from thegreatsuspender.

Requires a development of the tabs extensions to allow this. For more information, see here for the Chromium issue.

from thegreatsuspender.

I would like to see this soon. Its a great extension that deserves this.
Maybe add an "experimental-noted checkbox" which only checks for HTML5 <audio><video> tags, using what @kirb suggested (on his comment on Jun 5).

from thegreatsuspender.

If i was to implement this (highly considering it), what websites specifically should I be targetting? It seems that the audio/video !paused should be fairly easy. but with some quick tests this won't work for soundcloud or spotify. Any broad strokes I can make to detect flash audio/video? What about soundcloud? And are there other popular sites that I should be testing for?

from thegreatsuspender.

In addition to the 3 aforementioned websites, I would add:
Beatport.com (you can listen for free music there; the shop has moved to pro.beatport.com)
Hearthis.at
Hypem.com
Official.fm

from thegreatsuspender.

The audible tab functionality has now been baked into Chrome 46. Specifically, you should be able to query tab.audible to return a boolean value of whether the tab has produced sound in the last couple of seconds.

More info on the API: https://developer.chrome.com/extensions/tabs

from thegreatsuspender.

When is it planned to push out this feature?

from thegreatsuspender.

Well now?

from thegreatsuspender.