Comments (5)
Tejas-Shastha
commented on August 17, 2024
1
Whereas I could not solve this problem in Moveit itself, I found a simple enough workaround through testing with the robot. Narrowing the joint position limit windows by ~7% seems to work for the sequence of poses I test against.
Maybe MoveIt prepares position inside the limits, but the JTC making it go out of limits.
I think this makes the most sense, since it has been acknowledged that ros2_control does not yet respect joint limits. So I would reason out that the default planner OMPL/RRT prepares the trajectory with IK solutions that respect joint limits, but when the controller ros2_control/JTC tries to follow this trajectory, it sometimes arrives at different IK solutions that are unaware of joint limits.
In any case, since I am fairly certain that this is not a problem on the Franka side, I will close this issue.
@BarisYazici Thank you for the support!!
from franka_ros2.
BarisYazici
commented on August 17, 2024
I also noticed the limit parameters not processed by moveit. Is there sth we can do to fix? Or is it something moveit related?
from franka_ros2.
Tejas-Shastha
commented on August 17, 2024
So I poked around a bit and decided to pass the joint limits expressly through a YAML file based on franka_ros values, and indeed moveit now picks them up correctly:
robot_description_planning:
joint_limits:
panda_joint1:
has_acceleration_limits: true
has_effort_limits: true
has_jerk_limits: null
has_position_limits: true
has_velocity_limits: true
max_acceleration: 3.75
max_effort: 87
max_position: 2.8973
max_velocity: 2.175
min_position: -2.8973
panda_joint2:
has_acceleration_limits: true
has_effort_limits: true
has_jerk_limits: null
has_position_limits: true
has_velocity_limits: true
max_acceleration: 1.875
max_effort: 87
max_position: 1.7628
max_velocity: 2.175
min_position: -1.7628
panda_joint3:
has_acceleration_limits: true
has_effort_limits: true
has_jerk_limits: null
has_position_limits: true
has_velocity_limits: true
max_acceleration: 2.5
max_effort: 87
max_position: 2.8973
max_velocity: 2.175
min_position: -2.8973
panda_joint4:
has_acceleration_limits: true
has_effort_limits: true
has_jerk_limits: null
has_position_limits: true
has_velocity_limits: true
max_acceleration: 3.125
max_effort: 12
max_position: 2.8973
max_velocity: 2.61
min_position: -2.8973
panda_joint5:
has_acceleration_limits: true
has_effort_limits: true
has_jerk_limits: null
has_position_limits: true
has_velocity_limits: true
max_acceleration: 3.75
max_effort: 12
max_position: 1.7628
max_velocity: 2.61
min_position: -1.7628
panda_joint6:
has_acceleration_limits: true
has_effort_limits: true
has_jerk_limits: null
has_position_limits: true
has_velocity_limits: true
max_acceleration: 5.0
max_effort: 12
max_position: 3.7525
max_velocity: 2.61
min_position: -0.0175
panda_joint7:
has_acceleration_limits: true
has_effort_limits: true
has_jerk_limits: null
has_position_limits: true
has_velocity_limits: true
max_acceleration: 5.0
max_effort: 12
max_position: 2.8973
max_velocity: 2.61
min_position: -2.8973
However, this does not solve my problem and I still run into the reflex state with joint limits exceeded :( . The last time this happened, the joint values looked like this:
name:
- panda_joint1
- panda_joint2
- panda_joint3
- panda_joint4
- panda_joint6
- panda_joint7
- panda_joint5
position:
- -0.5846188414192806
- 0.5743862018374197
- -0.9308654554855968
- -0.0807863111203012
- 1.0447302227815072
- -0.03548325803408056
- -0.9017913305650664
velocity:
- 0.0005321018174672895
- -0.0004305121441906692
- 0.00015391332496071937
- -0.0004063499873393697
- -0.0002132338215014766
- -0.0019501103657266297
- 7.913850579020568e-05
effort:
- 0.17199018597602844
- -30.422439575195312
- -3.2222132682800293
- 5.280417442321777
- 1.5263864994049072
- 0.08953773230314255
- -1.359389066696167
From this I can surmise that the offending joint is panda_joint6: Actual value -0.03548325803408056, permitted range: (-0.0175, 3.7525). I also dug through the runtime environment and robot model->joint model group->get varibale bounds does indeed reflect these limits being properly set. So it seems like moveit planned a joint space trajectory that violated the limits.
I will try to look into this problem a bit more or post an issue in the moveit2 repo, but of course I would welcome any suggestions in this thread as well!!
from franka_ros2.
BarisYazici
commented on August 17, 2024
It might also worth looking at JTC. Maybe MoveIt prepares position inside the limits, but the JTC making it go out of limits. We recently added the old patched JTC to the repo. It might worth trying with that.
from franka_ros2.
Tejas-Shastha
commented on August 17, 2024
It might also worth looking at JTC. Maybe MoveIt prepares position inside the limits, but the JTC making it go out of limits. We recently added the old patched JTC to the repo. It might worth trying with that.
Unfortunately, we are using the FER1 robot with ROS2, so I am restricted to using libfranka v0.9.2 and and this repo at version v0.1.0. So I cannot try out the juicy new features being released :( .
from franka_ros2.
Related Issues (20)
- Gravity Compensation
- model_example_controller crashes in simulation HOT 1
- branch for supporting legacy robots with firmware version 4
- Control Error & Reflex Recovery HOT 3
- Reading and writing to the same hardware interface HOT 10
- Cartesian Stiffness Values Ignored HOT 1
- Error in prepare_command_mode_switch when running robotiq gripper controller HOT 1
- Position Command Interface Sensitivity & Control Exceptions HOT 2
- Parameterized Launch Configurations
- Franka Robot Simulation: Franka HW Sim HOT 1
- Problems with setup and example HOT 1
- Failed loading controller when using Humble dummy hardware
- Controller Development HOT 4
- cartesian_pose_example_controller Issue
- No movement while using fake_hardware HOT 1
- Franka Kinematics at Controller Level HOT 1
- [bug] can't run `joint_position_example_controller` with ubuntu realtime kernel HOT 1
- CMake Cannot Find `boost_sml` Headers in ROS 2 Workspace HOT 1
- Problem with libfranka HOT 1
- Cant control the real robot (Amika FR3) with MoveIt2 HOT 1
Recommend Projects
-
React
A declarative, efficient, and flexible JavaScript library for building user interfaces.
-
Vue.js
🖖 Vue.js is a progressive, incrementally-adoptable JavaScript framework for building UI on the web.
-
Typescript
TypeScript is a superset of JavaScript that compiles to clean JavaScript output.
-
TensorFlow
An Open Source Machine Learning Framework for Everyone
-
Django
The Web framework for perfectionists with deadlines.
-
Laravel
A PHP framework for web artisans
-
D3
Bring data to life with SVG, Canvas and HTML. 📊📈🎉
-
Recommend Topics
-
javascript
JavaScript (JS) is a lightweight interpreted programming language with first-class functions.
-
web
Some thing interesting about web. New door for the world.
-
server
A server is a program made to process requests and deliver data to clients.
-
Machine learning
Machine learning is a way of modeling and interpreting data that allows a piece of software to respond intelligently.
-
Visualization
Some thing interesting about visualization, use data art
-
Game
Some thing interesting about game, make everyone happy.
Recommend Org
-
Facebook
We are working to build community through open source technology. NB: members must have two-factor auth.
-
Microsoft
Open source projects and samples from Microsoft.
-
Google
Google ❤️ Open Source for everyone.
-
Alibaba
Alibaba Open Source for everyone
-
D3
Data-Driven Documents codes.
-
Tencent
China tencent open source team.
from franka_ros2.