Remove all test failed plugins from the README about asdf-plugins HOT 40 OPEN

I do recognize that there are issues for newer versions of mongodb, but its fix is not trivial, and I cannot work on fixing it right away. As such, please remove asdf-mongodb for now, and I will contact you again after fixing it.

from asdf-plugins.

@imbsky let's transfer it then!

from asdf-plugins.

hey @imbsky.
I'm willing to transfer the asdf-crystal as well, could you send a invitation?

from asdf-plugins.

@imbsky Just got asdf-rust fixed up, all green! Thanks for the reminder.

from asdf-plugins.

@marciogm Sent!

from asdf-plugins.

@imbsky it looks like there's some kind of issue with Travis CI's badge on that repo. The tests are actually passing, even though the badge says that they're not:

I opened Ibotta/asdf-brig#8 to see if they can fix up the badge, as I no longer have maintainer abilities on that repo.

from asdf-plugins.

@blimmer Thank you again for your quick response!

from asdf-plugins.

@imbsky Sorry for being late, I've fixed asdf-v. Thanks for the reminder!

from asdf-plugins.

@mikestephens I sent you an invitation!

from asdf-plugins.

@imbsky Fixed the asdf-scala plugin =)

from asdf-plugins.

Oh dang. I missed this one -- I can help out with asdf-brig (hey @blimmer!)

Since Ben was the only contributor no one @Ibotta got a notification of the issue he made for us. I've set myself as a watcher and will be fixing the build very soon.

from asdf-plugins.

I don't want to remove plugins automatically. GitHub checks have intermittent failures more frequently than I enjoy.

I did update the CI so commits on the default branch tests all plugins and summarizes the information. For example:

 * Checking plugins/vendir [FAILED]
*	FAIL: Expected plugin CI badge SVG to be passing but it was not: https://github.com/vmware-tanzu/asdf-carvel/workflows/test-all/badge.svg
* Checking plugins/ytt [FAILED]
*	FAIL: Expected plugin CI badge SVG to be passing but it was not: https://github.com/vmware-tanzu/asdf-carvel/workflows/test-all/badge.svg

Plugins available: 638
Plugin build checks passed: 549
Plugin build checks failed: 89

source - https://github.com/asdf-vm/asdf-plugins/actions/runs/4751694153/jobs/8441129580

I think there are ways to further automate this and report to the authors that there are issues, whether by tagging them in a thread in this repo or by opening Issues in the plugin repos. However, I don't feel the effort is worth the reward.

Very few people seem to complain about plugins actually not working. It's only a few times a year that we replace unmaintained plugins with new forks. Although some of the repos here might not work, they give people a place to fork from and then we can update this repo with their new plugins.

This is a health check at best. It isn't, and shouldn't, be a tool for people to gauge plugin health, robustness or trust. I try to point this out as much in this repo's README, SECURITY file and core tool documentation site.

from asdf-plugins.

I agree, not removing plugins directly, instead automating the notification of failed builds, with a warning of grace time, say 3 to 6 months to fix the build. It's more of a maintenance status check, and yeah I also doubt if it's worth the effort.

from asdf-plugins.

CC: @blimmer (Ibotta/asdf-brig)

from asdf-plugins.

CC: @nickveys, @gabecook (code-lever/asdf-rust)

from asdf-plugins.

Of course, I can help you run the test correctly again.

from asdf-plugins.

@sylph01 OK. I'm looking forward to your contact.

from asdf-plugins.

I currently don't have bandwidth to maintain asdf-php in any of the ways I would like to (new versions, optimisations, PHP extensions or fixing the tests), so I would agree to transfer it to this community if it starts moving and maintaining this kind of projects.

from asdf-plugins.

@odarriba We already manage a lot of plugins, for example the Standard ML plugin has been transferred by the author. If you okay, I will send you an invitation to prepare for the transfer.

from asdf-plugins.

@odarriba Sent!

from asdf-plugins.

@nickveys Thank you! Really quick work!

from asdf-plugins.

I fixed the asdf-crystal's CI and dealt with all issues.

from asdf-plugins.

Thank you for checking! Hmm, that's weird... We've created a great tool for GitHub Actions, so it might be a good idea to move to it. https://github.com/asdf-vm/actions

from asdf-plugins.

Sounds good. I opened Ibotta/asdf-brig#9 for them to consider, since I don't have maintainer privs anymore. Thanks!

from asdf-plugins.

@ndac-todoroki Great!

from asdf-plugins.

As a whole I think asdf community is a great thing, I'd be happy to pass asdf-elasticsearch off to that

from asdf-plugins.

@mtatheonly Thank you!

from asdf-plugins.

Nice, I'll also try fixing mines this weekend and transfer them.

from asdf-plugins.

Awesome! By the way, most plugins have been fixed by the author or community maintainer. Thanks to everyone who helped us.

from asdf-plugins.

This plugin was renamed to "Talos" per #151. Sorry... should have removed osctl. I can submit another PR to remove it.

from asdf-plugins.

@particledecay All right!

from asdf-plugins.

I just setup GitHub Actions on asdf-php in asdf-community/asdf-php#31!

from asdf-plugins.

I also added CI setup to elasticsearch.

from asdf-plugins.

Sorry for the late response, asdf-neovim is now green

from asdf-plugins.

@richin13 No worries! Thank you!

from asdf-plugins.

asdf-graalvm is green again.

from asdf-plugins.

Thanks!

from asdf-plugins.

asdf-brig has been fixed!

from asdf-plugins.

Thanks!

from asdf-plugins.

I think, this can be automated..

from asdf-plugins.